Image 01

CNN: 73% Say Start From Scratch (48%) or Stop Work Completely (25%) on Health Care Reform; UPDATE: 52% Oppose Use of Reconciliation

February 24th, 2010 by AHFF Geoff

President Barack Obama, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid May Want to Review CNN's Finding that 73% of the American Public Oppose Passing the Health Care Reform Bills before Congress now or Something Similar

This afternoon CNN released some troubling findings for the Obama Administration: Just 25% of the American public wants Congress to follow the lead of the newly released Obama Health Plan and pass a health care reform plan similar to the plans now before Congress. An overwhelming majority of Americans, 73%, prefer that Congress either start from scratch (48%) or stop work completely on health care reform (25%). Obama’s Health Plan contains essentially the same policies as the bill passed by the Senate, with the addition of price controls for health insurance premiums.

CNN buries the lede in its article accompanying the release of its findings, never mentioning that an overwhelming majority (73%) of the American public disapprove of passing a bill similar to the one before Congress, including four in ten Democrats who want the President and Congress to start over. CNN does manage to state that “nearly three quarters” of Americans want some kind of reform, including in that figure the 48% who want Congress to start over in that grouping in a somewhat dishonest fashion:

Washington (CNN) – Although the overall health care reform bills passed by the House of Representatives and the Senate are unpopular, many of the provisions in the existing bills are extremely popular, even among Republicans, according to a new national poll.

A CNN/Opinion Research Corporation survey released Wednesday also indicates that only a quarter of the public want Congress to stop all work on health care, with nearly three quarters saying lawmakers should pass some kind of reform.

Twenty-five percent of people questioned in the poll say Congress should pass legislation similar to the bills passed by both chambers, with 48 percent saying lawmakers should work on an entirely new bill and a quarter saying Congress should stop all work on health care reform.

…..

The poll’s release comes one day before a critical televised health care summit hosted by President Obama that will include top Congressional Democrats and Republicans.

The survey indicates nearly half of all Democrats say Congress should pass legislation similar to the bills passed by both chambers, with nearly 4 in 10 Democrats saying Congress should start from scratch and just 1 in 10 saying lawmakers should stop all work on health care.

A majority of Republicans questioned, 54 percent, want Congress to start from scratch, with just under 4 in 10 saying lawmakers should halt work on health care reform and just 6 percent saying Congress should pass into law the current legislation.

Fifty-two percent of Independents want Congress to start work on a new bill, with 27 percent saying lawmakers should stop all work, and 18 percent saying that the current legislation should be passed into law.

The final finding noted above in the CNN excerpt is truly incredible: a full 79% of Independents reject passing the current bills before Congress or something similar and only 18% of Independents favor moving forward with the present bills as advocated by the Obama Health Plan. That’s a 61 point gap between approval and disapproval, running against the plan initiated by the release of the Obama Health Plan last Monday and subsequent advocacy of the reconciliation process to circumvent the filibuster and push through Obamacare by the President and his Democratic congressional allies. With the mood of the country so clearly opposed to moving forward with the present bills or something similar in Congress, Obama must provide an incredible performance tomorrow to move public opinion back his way to convince nervous Democrats in Congress that proceeding with pushing through Obamacare now is in their best electoral interest.

UPDATE: Hotair points out that a new USAToday/Gallup poll taken yesterday shows the public opposed to Obama’s possible use of reconciliation to pass Obamacare by a 52%/39% margin and that only 22% of the public thinks the health care summit will result in a bipartisan deal.

White House press secretary Robert Gibbs indicated Monday that, if necessary, the White House was open to using a parliamentary maneuver known as reconciliation to bypass a prospective filibuster in the Senate. That means a measure could pass the Senate with a 51-vote majority rather than the 60 votes needed to end debate.

Americans are opposed 52%-39% to using that device to get a bill through.

The poll of 1,009 adults nationwide, taken by landline and cellphone Tuesday, has a margin of error of +/—4 percentage points.

UPDATE: Ace at Ace of Spades and Allahpundit at Hotair link over, thank you guys. Readers of Ace and Hotair please take a look around and leave a comment or three.

Be Sociable, Share!

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

28 Responses to “CNN: 73% Say Start From Scratch (48%) or Stop Work Completely (25%) on Health Care Reform; UPDATE: 52% Oppose Use of Reconciliation”

  1. […] Centristnet, behold the party public of no. The survey indicates nearly half of all Democrats say Congress […]

  2. irongrampa says:

    Great post–and a really nice layout overall, it’s quite easy to read.

    Nice job.

  3. AHFF Geoff says:

    @iron
    thanks for the compliment! I’m just figuring out this blogging thing…

  4. Leslie says:

    It would be great if the Repubs mention this poll tomorrow.

  5. AHFF Geoff says:

    @leslie

    Yes, we’ll see if the message gets through their thick skulls in both parties that the present plans are not supported by a large majority of Americans.

  6. […] Obama Health Plan and pass a health care reform plan similar to the plans now before Congress. BUT … CNN buries lede in its article that an overwhelming majority (73%) of the American publi… UPDATE: Hotair points out that a new USAToday/Gallup poll taken yesterday shows the public opposed […]

  7. […] up and smell the coffee. Poll, 73% of Americans say start over or ditch this entirely. 73% of the public doesn't want this bill. So why won't Democrats back off? Because they are […]

  8. […] Feb 25, 2010 at 9:57 am Posted by Steven in National 0 Comments A new CNN poll shows that only 25% of Americans favor passing the disasterous health care reform bills currently being debated in […]

  9. We need to start electing leaders who know the Constitution. Like Marco Rubio, Florida Senate Primary.

    http://www.cafepress.com/rubiocristobama

  10. AHFF Geoff says:

    @Santiago – Let my readers know how Rubio appeals to centrists and independents, if he does. Thanks.

  11. […] no longer have a filibuster-proof majority. This means that if they should try to push the massively unpopular health care bill through, the Republicans can use a filibuster to block its passage. The Democrats can, however, get […]

  12. […] CNN: 73% Say Start From Scratch or Stop Completely on HCR … […]

  13. […] CNN: 73% Say Start From Scratch or Stop Completely on HCR … […]

  14. Good post! I looked around for this… I located your site! 🙂 I have a Political Commentary site of my own at White Rabbit Cult… Anyway would you mind if I threw up a return link from my web site to your web site?

  15. […] average Americans overwhelmingly agree with this proposition, as recent CNN polling shows 73% want Obama and the Dems to either stop or start over instead of passing the present comprehensive plan and yesterday’s AP polling shows 68% want […]

  16. I have read over numerous of your current entries and I had been curious about if you wanted to swap blog site links? I am constantly seeking to switch links with personal blogs about very similar content! I look forward to hearing back from you before long.

  17. […] whose ideas I appreciated even though I disagreed with them. Split half and half? Hardly… CNN: 73% Say Start From Scratch or Stop Completely on HCR | CentristNet New CNN Poll: 59% Oppose Obamacare | The Foundry: Conservative Policy […]

  18. You made some good points there. I did a search on the topic and found most individuals will approve with your site.

  19. How nice to acquire information from a person! I just interact to inform you all the stuff are wonderful done to you page. Thanks plenty!

  20. china latest news…

    […]CNN: 73% Say Start From Scratch or Stop Completely on HCR | CentristNet[…]…

  21. Gertine says:

    I’d like to uslysht a little much more on this subject

  22. C’est incroyablement un plaisir de visiter votre site

  23. It is an autonomous UK public organization that was set up under the Immigration and Asylum Act of 1999.
    Attend Reiki shares with your teacher and other
    students. A Reiki practitioner does not need to understand the human energy system in order
    to support it.

  24. As well as her work with high fashion, Coco Chanel also created stage costumes for such plays as Cocteau’s
    Antigone (1923) and Oedipus Rex (1937) and film costumes for several
    movies, including Renoir’s La Regle de Jeu. Fashion is not something that exists in dresses only.
    The wholehearted devotion to follow teen fashion trends are considered by some as mere extravagance.

    My web-site … maternity party dresses

  25. My spouse and i get pleasure from, result in I uncovered just what I used to be interested in. You might have broken my 4 day prolonged quest! The lord Cheers gentleman. Have got a wonderful day. L8rs

  26. Un mɑgistral bravo à l’administrateur du blog

Leave a Reply